10 Best Natural Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes in 2022

With so many options, finding the best natural mascara for sensitive eyes can be overwhelming. There are so many things to consider such as ingredients, formula, brand name, price, and so much more. Needless to say, this can be pretty time-consuming.

To save you the hassle, we researched hundreds of products and sifted through thousands of customer reviews. Then we checked the ingredients, formula, efficacy, and price. Based on this, we bring you the best natural mascara for sensitive eyes. Let’s have a look.

Top 10 Best Natural Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes

SaleBestseller No. 1
Organic Mascara By Physicians Formula Organic Wear All Natural Origin Mascara, Organic Makeup, Black, Dermatologist Test
  • Volumizing and lengthening formula
  • Organic lash boosting complex, natural silk cotton and natural fibers volumize, thicken and separate each lash for a super dramatic eye
  • Recyclable eco-brush defines each lash with ultra-soft plastic bristles.
Bestseller No. 2
Burt's Bees 100% Natural Origin Nourishing Mascara, Black Brown - 0.4 Ounce
  • BLACK BROWN MASCARA: One mascara tube with convenient, easy-to-use applicator in Black Brown, perfect for all eye colors and skin tones
  • NOURISHING INGREDIENTS: 100% natural origin formula is made with Jojoba Oil and naturally moisturizing Glycerin which is gentle enough for the delicate eye area
  • STRENGTHEN & CONDITION: Our brush and formula work together to instantly give you long-lasting definition and softly nourish lashes
  • LENGTHENING MASCARA: This nourishing mascara lengthens and defines upper and lower lashes instantly for a beautiful look
  • NATURAL MAKEUP: This Burt’s Bees mascara is ophthalmologist-tested and safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Formulated without parabens, phthalates, SLS, petrolatum or synthetic fragrances. Never tested on animals
SaleBestseller No. 3
COVERGIRL Lash Blast Clean Volume Mascara, Very Black, 0.44 Fl Oz, Pack of 1
  • TURN UP THE VOLUME: COVERGIRL Lash Blast Clean Volume Mascara provides 10x the volume of bare lashes; Applicator brush separates and defines for visibly longer, fuller lashes
  • CLEAN, VEGAN FORMULA: This lash-loving vegan mascara is infused with argan and marula oils and is formulated without parabens, sulfates, talc, or mineral oil
  • FSC CERTIFIED: Packaging is made from 80% recycled paper from well-managed forests
  • CRUELTY-FREE: COVERGIRL products are Leaping Bunny Certified by Cruelty-Free International, meaning they are never tested on animals
SaleBestseller No. 4
Rimmel KIND & FREE Clean Mascara, Cruelty-Free & Vegan, 002 Brown Black, 0.23 Fl Oz
  • clean, conditioning volume & length
  • formulated with organic shea butter and biotin
  • bio-based brush made from 100% bio-based fibers
  • 99% of ingredients of natural origin
  • Waterproof, without perfumes
Bestseller No. 5
Poppy Austin Mascara 9g - Lash Mascara - 100% Organic Mascara, Paraben-Free, Vegan, Cruelty-Free Mascara Black - Hypoallergenic Mascara Lengthening & Volumising with Argan Oil
  • Lash Strengthening Mascara - Your eye organic makeup kit is not complete without Poppy Austin eyelash growth mascara. If you need the best mascara for thickening and lengthening, we got just the thing. Enjoy a long-lasting lift and curl for 24 hours!
  • Nourishing Formula - Looking for the best mascara for length and volume without harsh ingredients? Our lash extending mascara waterproof formula is vegan and has argan oil. Revitalize your lashes from root to tip with our black oil mascara.
  • Flake-Resistant & Smudge-Proof - Say goodbye to clumpy lashes and hello to fluttery ones with our no smudge mascara. This flake free mascara for sensitive eyes gives you beautifully long lashes with dramatic volume. Let your eyelashes steal the show minus the smearing!
  • Gentle on Sensitive Eyes - With our vegan and hypoallergenic mascara, sensitive eyes are well cared for. Its soft, full-bristle applicator seamlessly glides through your lashes for a well-defined look. No itchy and watery eyes after use!
  • Simple Solutions, Real Results - At Poppy Austin, we keep things simple yet effective, like our skincare products. If you're not satisfied with your purchase, please feel free to contact us and our customer service will assist you.
SaleBestseller No. 6
Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara + Lash Primer | 2-in-1 Boosts Lash Length, Volume & Definition | Silicone Free, Paraben Free, Dermatologist & Ophthalmologist Tested | 0.2 Fl Oz, Black
  • New look, same great formula; packaging may vary
  • Award-winning, bestselling double-sided mascara plus lash primer for ultimate length and volume
  • Ophthalmologist Tested
  • Cruelty free
  • EWG Certified
  • 100% tree-free paper carton
  • MADE WITH: Jojoba Esters
  • MADE WITHOUT: Parabens, Paraffins, Synthetic Fragrances, Silicones, Mineral Oil
SaleBestseller No. 7
Vegan Black Mascara for Sensitive Eyes, Natural Hypoallergenic mascara, Buildable Lengthening and Volumizing for Natural Looking, Cruelty Free, Ophthalmologist Tested- By Gaya cosmetics
  • VEGAN LUXURY MASCARA FOR SENSITIVE EYES - Ophthalmologically tested, suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lenses wearers. Our Ultra Black Colour Conditioning Mascara is a Unique Masterpiece
  • ANIMAL CRUELTY FREE SAFE EYE LASH ENHANCER - Paraben Free with No Harmful Ingredients. Makes Thin Fine Upper & Lower Eyelashes Longer & Thicker. Suitable for Contact Lenses
  • BUILDABLE VOLUME CONTROL WITH PROFESSIONAL CURVED WAND - Full Boost on Lashes by Building, Volumizing & Extending Them. Natural Looking Impact or Voluminous Thick Fake False Effect Without Falsies or Extensions
  • SEPARATE & LENGTHEN LASHES WITH NO CLUMPS - Length Defining Top Coat Mascara with Smudgeproof Silicone Brush. No Clumping & Won't Smudge Under the Eyes. Clear Definition for Great Extended Super Blast Lashes
  • LONG LASTING YET EASY TO APPLY & REMOVE - 3d Conditioning Best Selling Mascara. Add the Blackest Eyelash Volumizer to Your Travel Sized Make Up Cosmetics Gifts List. Wear for an Amazing Epic Look
Bestseller No. 8
Pacifica Beauty Stellar Gaze Length & Strength Black Mascara, For Volume and Length, Vitamin B + Coconut, Natural Lash Effect, Silicone, Sulfate + Paraben Free, Vegan and Cruelty Free
  • Super plush vegan brush
  • Lengthening formula
  • Deep intensity color
  • It’s a Formulated without talc, parabens, phthalates or mineral oil.
  • This amazing formula is infused with coconut oil and vitamin B to hydrate each lash as it lengthens, strengthens and adds volume.
SaleBestseller No. 9
Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara for Stronger, Longer Lashes, Clump-, Smudge- and Flake-Free Mascara with Olive Oil, Vitamin E and Rice Protein, Black 02,.21 oz
  • .21-ounce tube of Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Lash-Lengthening and Strengthening Mascara to help grow your lashes to their fullest potential
  • Formulated with antioxidant vitamin E, rice protein, and olive oil, this mascara nourishes and strengthens for lashes that look up to 100% longer with a formula that won't clump, smudge, or flake
  • On the outside, the soft-bristle brush combs through every lash from root to tip, smoothly applying antioxidant-rich color for outstanding definition and intensity while the formula of this eye makeup helps extend and strengthen lashes from inside
  • This dermatologist- & ophthalmologist-tested brand is safe and gentle for people with sensitive eyes & contact lens wearers for use in part of a regular makeup routine
  • Easily remove this lash-lengthening mascara with the Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover or soap & water
SaleBestseller No. 10
Physicians Formula Rosé All Day Mascara Black Volumizing, Hypoallergenic, Conditioning, Nourishing, Lifting, Lengthening, Dermatologist Approved
  • COLOR FOR CHEEKS, EYES, & LIPS: This easy-to-use color stick adds a touch of sheer, gorgeous color to eyes, lips, & cheeks. Our formula blurs, protects, perfects, & fights signs of aging.
  • PERFECT & PROTECT: This ultra-blendable formula combines our 360° Total Defense Complex to defend against harmful sunrays (SPF), blue light (RPF), & pollution (PPF), with effortless color for a natural, all-over look.
  • BEST FACE FORWARD: With primers, highlighters, bronzers, & mineral powders, we have a full line of makeup to help you build a foundation for any look, all made without irritants or harsh additives.
  • SENSITIVE SKIN CARE: Physician's Formula offers a full line of skin care & makeup for sensitive skin, including mascaras, lipsticks, concealers, eyeshadow palettes, bb creams, bronzers & primers.
  • HEALTHY BEAUTY: All of our makeup & skincare products are hypoallergenic, safe for sensitive skin & eyes, & made without any of the 150+ known harsh ingredients found in other personal care items.

Things to Consider When Buying the Best Natural Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes

Ingredients

When it comes to choosing the best natural mascara for sensitive eyes, the most important thing to consider is the ingredients. If you’re particularly allergic to a specific ingredient, make sure to only choose products that don’t contain it. This way, you won’t experience allergies or irritation when using a natural mascara.

Price

Another important thing to consider is the price. You shouldn’t always chase the cheapest product on the market as it can cause problems in the long run. Similarly, just because a product is expensive doesn’t mean that it’s the right product for you. Make sure to do your due diligence when shopping for the best natural mascara for sensitive eyes.

Avoid Harsh Chemicals

When looking for the best natural mascara for sensitive eyes, it’s better to avoid harsh chemicals. Generally, it’s better to look for a product that doesn’t contain synthetic fragrances, parabens, sulfates, phthalates, etc. Even the reputable products can sometimes contain these chemicals, it’s important to look at the formula. Too much of these chemicals can be bad for you.

Star Rating

If a product is well-received on Amazon, chances are it’s usually pretty good. These reviews are generally a testament to the efficacy of a product. When shopping for the best natural mascara for sensitive eyes, you should usually go with product with the star rating of 3. 5 or more. The higher the better!

Read Customer Reviews

Reading customer reviews can also be helpful when purchasing the best natural mascara for sensitive eyes. It’s possible that someone else who has the same needs as you has already tried and reviewed the product. Reading their review will give you an idea on whether or not the natural mascara you’re looking to buy is worth your time and money.

Brand Name

Finally, when it comes to beauty, skincare, or hair care products, it’s usually better to stick with reputable products. There are so many products available on the market, but the brands which have stood the test of time are the ones that you should generally go for. At the same time, don’t be afraid of experimenting with new products.

Patch Test

No matter which natural mascara you’re considering, it’s important to do a patch test first (even if a product is well-received). Everyone is different and so are their needs. So, always be sure to do a patch test when you try out a new product.

Conclusion

It can be challenging to find the best natural mascara for sensitive eyes. However, we’ve done all the heavy-lifting for you. We hope this article helped you find the best natural mascara for your needs.

Which one of these natural mascaras are you going to try? Let us know in the comments below. If you have any questions, ask away.

Leave a Comment